Cody Howrigon
Restaurant Review
Intended Publication: The Index
When consulting with various friends and family about where to have dinner this past weekend, I heard much praise for a place called, North 11 Bistro and Brew. “It’s like a fine dining place to eat. They have really good food and service, too.” This seemed to be the general consensus from people I know who have eaten there. I thought all of this praise seemed a bit suspicious, as I have lived in the area all my life and hadn’t heard about this great place before. I decided to take a deeper look and check it out for myself.
Established in 2003 and just a ten minute drive from campus, North 11 offers a diverse selection of alleged gourmet burgers and “well made” drinks. The menu is vast, and includes just about everything from seafood to Tex-Mex.
Abundant with choices and hospitality it is, but fine dining it is not.
My first impression after walking into North 11 can be summed up with one word - loud. As my father and I were being shown to our seats, I couldn’t help but notice how it gets considerably louder the further into the restaurant you go. I mean, the place wasn’t even all the way full, and the decibel level had to be on par with that of a middle school cafeteria. That said, people were having a really good time. Part of this I think has to do with the open atmosphere. The restaurant is split into three sections. On one side is the bar, which has undergone an obvious facelift in recent years, making the rest of the restaurant look years in the past. The middle section is the main dining area, where I was seated, and is where the majority of the customers are located. The third section is essentially extra dining space, used for the overflow of dining patrons on weekends. The lack of big screen TVs on the walls are an indication of the kind of people that eat here - people who are interested in having conversations with one another, not people looking for a place to simply stuff their face and watch the big game.
After my father and I sat down at our table, we were soon greeted by our waitress with ice water. After scanning the menu’s many options, a good number of them caught my eye - Beef Burgundy Steak Tips, Pecan Encrusted Walleye, Bourbon Haystack Burger, Personal Pizza, and Open Faced Pesto Salmon - were among the most appealing. I decided I had to try the 12 oz. Prime Rib, and my dad chose the Portobello Melt. Our waitress promptly took our order and convinced us to get a couple of appetizers as well, before hurrying back to the kitchen.
My dad had ordered a short Jack and Coke - “half n’ half”. It came out tall, weak, and a bit late. This was more of a minor distraction than a catastrophic mistake, as we were generally satisfied with the overall quality of service. The servers and bussers could be seen rushing from point A to point B at any time throughout the night, hurriedly taking orders and clearing tables with nothing but smiles on their face.
Our appetizers came out quickly - Prime Rib Bruschetta and Crab Rangoons - both of which I believe, made me a better person for having eaten them. The presentation of the Bruschetta alone was beautiful. It was so aesthetically pleasing in fact, that I felt shame for even considering eating it. The slices of meat were rich with garlic and feta, and the oval shaped crackers they laid upon were the perfect level of moist, after having been soaked in burgundy reduction for precisely the right amount of time. The Crab Rangoons were undoubtedly tasty, but less so than the Bruschetta. They are a mixture of crab, cream cheese and scallions, folded into a fried wonton dumpling that is about the size of a regulation-size softball. We made quick work of both appetizers, and felt great remorse after they were gone.
The main event of the evening followed shortly after. My 12 oz. Prime Rib and my dad’s Portobello Melt seemed to glow on the table before us. The Prime Rib was cooked to the perfect medium-rare temperature I had requested, giving it the tender juiciness common to all great steaks. I have come to understand that the the measure of all truly great steaks, is when you can eat them without steak sauce and actually enjoy them more. This was one of those steaks. My father was kind enough to offer me half of his Portobello Melt, but, I am traditionally not a big fan of eating what I consider to be large hunks of fungus. In fact, I normally find it straight-out revolting. However, due to the adventurous spirit I happened to be in at the time, I took him up on his offer. This was easily the best “hunk of fungus” I had ever tried, bar none. I not only took a bite of the half he cut off for me, but I finished it with a smile on my face. Any restaurant that can pull a complete 180 on someone like that has to be doing something right.
Although North 11 is not a place to go if you’re looking for a fine dining experience, it is a place to enjoy loud, energetic conversation with friends and family, while eating above average food in an above average atmosphere. The service is prone to mistakes as it is at most any restaurant, but they compensate for where they lack with raw effort and an upbeat attitude. The kitchen deserves all the praise they have been given and more. The food is sublime, and the presentation is artful. When dining at North 11, there is evidence everywhere for why they have survived for so long. The owners have made obvious efforts to reimagine their space, and they make good on their promise to provide personable service and high-quality food and drinks. This is a place I recommend to everyone in the area who is interested to take the time to visit. I’m confident you will enjoy the experience.